In Ear Monitors for an L1 User
 This article expresses my opinion and experience. Please post comments to Twitter @ST_Muso or LinkedIn @STPro. Thank you — ST. |
In-Ear Monitors for an L1 User?
Having played in front of my L1 systems for years, I never expected to get stage monitors or in-ears. One of the key aspects of the L1 Approach was no monitors. But the L1 Pro models are considerably louder than the legacy L1 systems.
I just got my In-Ear-Monitors — EW IEM G4 Twin
Related article: Sennheiser EW IEM G4
Here are my first impressions of the wireless system.
Update, I have now upgraded from the stock earphones to
See The In Ear Monitors (below) for more details.
Why In-Ear Monitors?
I don't use monitors
I've been playing in front of my L1 systems since June 2004. On extremely shallow stages, I have had to stand beside my L1, but in all this time, I can't recall setting up a monitor for me. I have enjoyed the sound of the L1 behind me, and the sense of being in the same sound field as my audiences. I felt it was the responsible thing to do - being downstream from my output before subjecting my audiences to it.
So why get In-Ear Monitors?
- The L1 Pro16 (118 dB SPL) and the L1 Pro32 (122 dB SPL) are both louder than the L1 Model II (115 dB SPL).
- I rarely played the L1 Model II at the maximum volume, but when I did, I wore ear protection. On those occasions, I thought about in-ear monitors. It's going to be tempting to go all out with the L1 Pro systems from time to time and I don't want to be standing in front of them when I do. I'll set them up at the front of the stage and use the in-ear monitors to hear myself. I'll be able to do this at a lower volume and avoid damaging my hearing.
- Convenience for Rehearsal
- If it isn't convenient to set up the L1 for practice or rehearsal (e.g., playing at home or anywhere you might disturb others), in-ear monitors can give you the auditory experience of playing at gig volume.
- Getting Your Tone
- To hear the tone of your voice and instrument as your audience will hear it, you have to rehearse at gig volume. With in-ear monitors, you can do that and have a consistent experience as you move from rehearsal to performance
- Remote Loudspeakers
- Sometimes I have to set up remote loudspeakers. I can use the in-ear monitor system to do that.
Where Do I Connect the In-Ear Monitors?
You'll likely have two options: Main Mix or Monitor Mix (if you have a mixer). There are advantages and disadvantages to both.
Main Mix
Sending the Main Mix to your In-Ear Monitors (IEMs) is easy and has the advantage that what you hear in the IEMs is (roughly) the same as what your audience hears coming out of your main system (L1 Pro, S1 Pro, ToneMatch mixer, etc.). That means that any adjustments to volume, tone, or reverb will not only be heard in the room but also in the IEMs.
Advantages of the Main Mix for IEMs
- Simple to connect
- You hear (approximately) what the audience hears
It is simple to connect to the Main Mix if you have a Line Out from your system. All of these Bose models do, and they are balanced connections.
- All L1 Pro (XLR)
- S1 Pro (1/4 inch (6.3 mm) Tip-Ring-Sleeve) and S1 Pro+ (XLR)
- L1 Compact (1/4 inch (6.3 mm) Tip-Ring-Sleeve)
- ToneMatch mixers (all have analog Main or Master Outputs in addition to the ToneMatch Port)
- The T4S/T8S have headphone jacks the can be used for IEMs
The L1 Classic, L1 Model 1, L1 Model II, and L1 Model 1S do not have Line Out connections
You may need some adapters depending on the input connection(s) to your IEM system.
Disadvantages of the Main Mix for IEMs
- This is not as flexible or adaptable as using a separate monitor mix. If you adjust the sound for the room, the sound in the IEMs changes too.
Monitor Mix
All the ToneMatch mixers have Aux outputs. These can be used to create a separate monitor mix. You can read about that here
- T1 Aux (one Aux output)
- T4S Aux Outputs (two Aux outputs)
- T8S Aux Outputs (four Aux outputs)
Advantages of a Separate Monitor Mix
For each output on your mixer, you can
- Have a different mix of vocals vs. instruments
- Example: for singers - "more me" in the monitors
- Different effects or reverb levels compared to the Main Mix
- Example: More or less reverb in the monitors vs. the main listening room. In an extremely reverberant room, you might not add any reverb, but your vocalists may prefer to hear reverb in the IEMs
- You can have a consistent mix for your IEMs that doesn't have to change to suit the acoustics of different venues
Disadvantages of a Monitor Mix for IEMs
- Requires a mixer with the ability to create one or more monitor mixes
- Setting up a monitor mix is more complex and may require some additional cables and adapters
- The rest of the article will deal with specific equipment listed at the top of the page
First Time Setup
The Sennheiser system worked out of the box. I connected the headphone output of my T8S ToneMatch Mixer to the inputs of the transmitter to try things out quickly. I took time to get to learn the details after several hours of spontaneous fun.
First Impressions
- The Gear
The equipment makes a great first impression. The screens on the base unit and belt pack are bright, high-resolution, and easy to read. Everything feels solid and road-worthy.
- Guitar
The guitar through the Kemper Profiler sounds great through the in-ear-monitors, but to put that into context, I'm used to hearing it through my L1 Pro32. It's not massively different.
- Vocals
I usually run the vocals dry in the PA (no reverb or time-related effects) because there's usually plenty of natural reverberation in the room. That means the headphone mix is dry, too - drier than what I usually hear (voice in the room sound). That's okay. I don't mind.
It will take some time to get used to the occlusion effect (try singing with your fingers in your ears). The guitar sounds fine. My voice sounds funny. When I have more time, I'll set up a proper monitor mix to control the vocal and guitar levels separately.
I'll need to rehearse with the in-ear-monitors to get used to hearing myself that way. Don't get in-ear monitors and experience them for the first time at a gig. Get to know them first.
Later Impressions
Several hours later.
Wow - I wish I had gotten wireless in-ear-monitors sooner.
The best part is the wireless. Back when I had to consider the neighbours and cohabitants, I would occasionally play with headphones. I hated it - mostly because I play standing up and I wander around. Within minutes I was a tangled mess. You find out quickly if you tend to turn in one direction when there are cables involved. I went wireless for the guitar a long time ago, which made using headphones all the more vexing.
Remember the first time you played wireless with your guitar on stage? I got to relive that all over again with wireless monitoring.
I'm still getting used to the earbuds and the occlusion effect when I'm singing. When I want to give that a rest, I can use regular headphones that plug into the wireless receiver. My Bose NC 700 headphones work fine.
The initial setup was drop-dead simple, but there are plenty of options, including a limiter so I won't blow out my ears.
I have lots of wireless gear but this stands out from the rest. The belt-pack receiver has a clear, easy-to-read display. The construction feels solid (all metal) compared to all my other plastic belt packs.
Why UHF instead of 2.4 Mhz Digital?
If you're wondering why I went with a UHF system instead of one of the less expensive 2.4 MHz systems - it's because the 2.4 MHz range is crowded. I don't want to get to a gig and find that all the available channels are occupied by the ubiquitous wireless guitar and microphone systems. I may be wrong, but I predict there will problems when all those players who got 2.4 Mhz wireless systems while we were locked down, show up on stage together for the first time.
Why the Twin System
I got the package deal with two receivers for two reasons.
- The system is stereo, but you can split the signals and have two monitor mixes - one for each receiver. If necessary, I can use the system for two people.
- You can run remote loudspeakers for larger venues in stereo or dual mono. See Sennheiser EW IEM G4 for details
Related Material
Mixing Live Sound - IEMS & Monitors
The In-Ear Monitors
The IE 4 Earphones that came with the Sennheiser IEM G4 Twin transmitter/receiver are perfectly functional, but I was curious about higher-end products to put in my ears. I got three:
- Sennheiser IE 100 Pro Wireless Bluetooth (these came later)
- Sennheiser IE 400 Pro
- Sennheiser IE 500 Pro
General Comments
All three models in the Pro series share the same shape, fit, silicon and foam earpieces, and connectors to cables and the Bluetooth accessory. I found I could get a good seal for passive isolation, and they were comfortable for hours.
Differences
Initially, I got the IE 400 Pro and IE 500 Pro, intending to keep just one. It turns out, I liked them both immensely for different reasons. I'm more inclined to use the IE 500 Pro on stage and the IE 400 Pro when I'm working on my tone or mixing. Mixing with in-ears? That's the subject of another article about dearVR Mix.
The IE 400 Pro has a flatter frequency response than the IE 500 Pro. The IE 400 Pro is great for clinical listening like when I'm working on my vocal or guitar tone. The IE 500 Pro has a more flattering frequency response that is easier to listen to for long periods. It's slightly less pronounced in the upper mids than the IE 400 Pro. This is good for me as a vocalist because it encourages me to be more articulate. My voice tends to be darker and I can be muddy if I'm not concentrating. The IE 500 Pro help me with that.
Sennheiser makes the IE Pro BT connector, a Bluetooth receiver that works with all of its Pro series In-Ear Monitors. With this, you can convert your professional In-Ear monitors into Bluetooth earbuds. It's a short cable with a bump for the controls and a bump for the battery. You plug the In-Ears into it and you have wireless earbuds that sound great. I could have purchased it separately but I got this bundled with the Sennheiser IE 100 Pro Wireless Bluetooth out of curiosity. The IE 100 Pro sounds remarkably good and I could use them on stage in a pinch.
Reviews
Sennheiser IE 500 Pro headphonecheck.com
Sennheiser IE 500 Pro head-fi.org